How To Make Enamel Pins Step By Step

September 11, 2023
August 2, 2023

| min read

From preparing your artwork file to finding a trusted manufacturer follow this step by step guide to successfully create an enamel pin.

How Do I Prepare an Enamel Pin Artwork File

When it comes to making an enamel pin, the first step is to prepare your artwork file. This is where your creativity truly shines! Start by creating a design that reflects your vision and style. Whether you're an illustrator, graphic designer, or simply have a knack for doodling, let your imagination run wild.

Once you have your design ready, it's important to ensure that the file meets the specifications required by manufacturers. Make sure the artwork is in vector format to maintain high quality and scalability. Convert any text into outlines to avoid font issues and double-check that all colors are properly labeled with Pantone or CMYK values.

Remember, attention to detail is key when preparing your artwork file. Check for any spelling errors or inconsistencies in line thicknesses before finalizing it. By taking the time to meticulously review and refine your design, you'll be one step closer to bringing your enamel pin creation to life!

If artwork isn’t your thing, no worries, most pin manufacturers offer free artwork.  They are motivated to prepare your artwork for free so you will buy the pins from them.   All you need is a basic idea, even if it is just a simple written description of a rudimentary concept.

To illustrate how easy it is to prepare artwork, do the following.  Email a pin manufacturer such as CustomPinsNow.com.  Tell them your idea such as: I need a baseball trading pin for my little league baseball team that is red and white, includes a baseball, the year, and my team name. They will take this information and professionally design you a cool trading pin.  You will be amazed at how easy it is.

What Type of Enamel Pin Should I Choose

When it comes to making a custom an enamel pin, one of the first decisions you'll need to make is what type your pin will be made from. This choice will not only affect the overall look and feel of your pin, but also its durability and cost.

One option is soft enamel, which is a popular choice for many pin designs. A soft enamel pin has raised metal borders with recessed areas that are filled with colored enamel. This gives them a textured and dimensional appearance. A soft enamel pin is relatively affordable and offer a wide range of color options.

Another option is hard enamel, which provides a smooth and polished finish. A hard enamel pin is a flat surface because the colored enamels are filled right to the edge of the raised metal border like soft enamel and then heated and hardened and polished smooth.  A hard enamel pin tends to be more durable than soft enamel, but they also come at a higher price point.

There's also the option of choosing other types such as die struck or printed pins if you prefer a different aesthetic for your design. These types can provide unique looks like antique finishes or full-color gradient printing.

The type you choose for your custom lapel pin will play an important role in determining its appearance, durability, and cost. Whether you go with soft or hard enamel or explore alternative options like die struck or printed pins, take into consideration both your budget and desired design outcome when making this decision.

To illustrate how to choose the right type of enamel pin consider this.  Soft enamel is most economical and works well for most purposes like pin trading and giveaways.  Hard enamel is the highest quality and works well for corporate branding and employee recognition.  Die struck gives you a classic gold or silver look and works well for subtle distinguished purposes.  Printed is the least popular but works well when you have gradient colors you need to match.

What Size Should My Enamel Pin Be

When it comes to deciding the size of your enamel pin, there are a few factors to consider. First and foremost, think about the design of your pin. Is it intricate with lots of details? Or is it a simple and bold statement piece? The complexity of your design will play a role in determining the optimal size.

Next, think about how you plan on using your enamel pin. Will it be worn on clothing or as an accessory on a backpack or hat? If so, you'll want to choose a size that is visible but not overwhelming. On the other hand, if you're creating pins for collecting, trading or displaying purposes, you may opt for larger sizes to showcase the artwork more prominently.  When it comes to trading - bigger is always better.

Consider any specific requirements or limitations set by your manufacturer or supplier. They may have guidelines regarding minimum and maximum sizes that can be produced efficiently and cost-effectively.

Choosing the right size for your enamel pin involves finding a balance between aesthetics, practicality, and manufacturing considerations. Take some time to experiment with different sizes before finalizing your decision!

To illustrate sizing applications, consider these examples.  If your pin is for trading purposes like baseball, hockey or Disney bigger is always better.  1.5 to 2 inches is the most common size.  if your pin is for a suit lapel stick to a small pin like .75 to 1 inch in diameter.  If your pin is for corporate branding, tradeshow, conventions stick to a 1 to 1.25 inch size pin.

How Many Enamel Pins Should I Produce

When it comes to making an enamel pin, one important decision you need to make is how many pins you want to produce. The quantity of an enamel pin can have an impact on the overall cost and production time.

Consider your purpose for creating the pins. Are they for personal use or are you planning to sell them? If it's for personal use, a smaller quantity might be sufficient. However, if you're planning to sell them or give them away as promotional items, a larger quantity may be more economical.

Think about your budget and storage capabilities. Ordering a larger quantity may lower the per-unit cost but requires more space for storage. Make sure you have enough room to store the extra inventory.

Consider the demand for your pins. If there is high demand or if you plan on distributing them at events or through an online store, ordering a larger batch can ensure that you don't run out of stock too quickly.

Deciding how many enamel pins to produce ultimately depends on factors such as budget, purpose, and demand. Take these into consideration when determining the right quantity for your needs!

To illustrate this decision consider the following.  If you are buying for a little league baseball team going to a tournament, consider the number of boys on your team and the number of teams that will be there trading.  Smaller tournaments its best to order 100 to 300 pins and 500 to 1000 for larger tournaments.  If you are buying for a tradeshow and the pins are for giveaway 500 to 1000 is a good number depending on the size of the show.

How Many Pin-Backs Should My Enamel Pin Have

Deciding how many pin-backs you want your enamel pin to have is an important consideration in the production process and one that is often overlooked. Pin-backs are the fasteners that secure the pin to clothing or accessories.  They are also known as clutches, locking backs and deluxe clutch.

First, consider how you plan to use your enamel pins. If they will be worn on jackets or backpacks, you may want multiple pin-backs for added security and stability. On the other hand, if they will be used as decorative items or collectibles, a single pin-back may suffice.

Next, think about your target audience and their preferences. Some people prefer pins with two backings to prevent twisting or spinning, while others find one sufficient. It's essential to strike a balance between functionality and aesthetics when making this decision.

Consider your budget and manufacturing capabilities. More pin-backs mean higher production costs and potentially longer lead times. Assess whether the additional expense is worth it based on your intended use of the pins.

To illustrate, consider the following.  If the enamel pin is worn on an expensive suit lapel most people cringe at putting a hole in their clothing so one pin-back is preferred.  If the enamel pin is worn on a hat, two pin-backs are best to hold the pin secure and straight.

How To Find a Factory To Produce Enamel Pins

Once you have finalized your artwork and decided on the type, size, and quantity of your enamel pins, it's time to find a factory to bring your vision to life. Look for a manufacturer that specializes in custom pin production and has experience working with enamel materials.

Start by conducting thorough research online to find reputable manufacturers that offer high-quality products at competitive prices. Read customer reviews and testimonials to get an idea of their reliability and the quality of their work. You can also ask for recommendations from fellow pin enthusiasts or join online communities dedicated to pin collecting.

When reaching out to potential factories, make sure to communicate your specific requirements clearly. Provide them with all the necessary details such as artwork files, desired pin backing options, plating preferences, and any additional customization features you may want.

Don't forget about pricing! Request quotes from multiple manufacturers so you can compare costs before making a decision. Keep in mind that factors like pin size, quantity ordered, metal finish choices, and add-ons will affect the overall cost.

To illustrate, consider the following.  There are hundreds of pin manufacturers online.  The difference boils down to price, speed and service.  Having been in the industry for years I like to recommend two factories:  CustomPinsNow.com and PinProsPlus.com - both companies have been around for years and proven to have competitive pricing, great turnaround and exceptional customer service.

Custom Pin Customer Reviews

When it comes to choosing a factory to produce your custom enamel pins, customer reviews can be incredibly helpful in making an informed decision. Hearing from those who have already worked with the manufacturer can give you valuable insights into their quality, reliability, and customer service.

One of the best ways to find out about customer experiences is by reading online reviews. Websites like Yelp, Google, or even social media platforms often feature feedback from customers who have purchased custom pins in the past. Take note of any recurring positive or negative comments as they can indicate consistent patterns in the manufacturer's performance.

It's also worth reaching out to other businesses or individuals within your industry who may have ordered custom pins before. They may be able to provide firsthand recommendations based on their own experiences. Connecting with others who have gone through the same process can give you peace of mind knowing that you're making an educated choice for your enamel pin production.

How different are Soft Enamel Pins vs Hard Enamel Pins

When it comes to choosing between soft and hard enamel pins, there are a few key differences to consider.

The main distinction lies in the texture and finish of the pins. Soft enamel pins have raised metal edges with recessed colored areas, giving them a textured feel. On the other hand, hard enamel pins have a smooth and polished surface as the enamel is filled right to the top of the raised borders, heated and polished smooth.  Soft enamel has a dimensional look and feel.  Hard enamel has a smooth polished look and feel.

Durability is another factor to keep in mind. While both types of pins are durable, hard enamel pins tend to be more resilient as the enamel has been hardened. This makes them less prone to scratching or chipping compared to soft version.

Cost can also play a role in your decision-making process. Soft enamel pins are generally more affordable than their hard enamel counterparts due to their simpler manufacturing process.

How Much Does It Cost to Get Custom Pins Made?

The price of custom pins can vary depending on several factors, such as the pin size, design complexity, and quantity ordered.

The size of the pin is one of the main factors that influence the cost. Larger pins generally require more materials and production time, so they tend to be more expensive. Similarly, intricate designs with fine details may also increase the overall cost due to additional labor involved in manufacturing.

Another consideration is the quantity of pins you want to produce. Ordering larger quantities often leads to lower per-unit costs because factories can take advantage of economies of scale. On the other hand, ordering smaller quantities may result in higher costs per unit.

Different customization options like specialized plating finishes or extra colors can add to the total cost. These enhancements provide a unique look but come at an additional expense.

When it comes to determining how much it will cost for custom pin production, considering these factors will help you get an estimate tailored specifically for your needs.

To illustrate, consider the following.  If you are buying 300 quantity, 1.5 inch soft enamel little league baseball trading pins you would expect to pay $1.80 to $2.00 per pin.  If  you are buying 100 quantity, 1 inch hard enamel pins for your business you would expect to pay $2.75 to $2.95 per pin.

What are Enamel Pin Upgrades or Accessories

When it comes to making enamel pins, there are plenty of options for upgrading your design. Pin upgrades can take your pin from ordinary to extraordinary and make it stand out in a crowd. One popular pin upgrade is adding glitter or glow-in-the-dark enamel. These enhancements add a unique touch and make your pin truly eye-catching.

Another option for pin upgrades is the addition of special effects like pearlized or translucent enamel. These effects create a beautiful, multi-dimensional look that adds depth and interest to your design. You can also choose to have your pins plated with different metals such as gold, silver, or black nickel for added sophistication.

Additionally, you can opt for other customizations like danglers or spinners that add movement and interaction to your pins. These extra features not only make your pins more visually appealing but also provide a fun element that people will love.

Pin upgrades offer endless possibilities when it comes to creating unique and memorable designs. Whether you want to add sparkle with glitter enamel or incorporate special effects, these enhancements will help elevate your enamel pins to the next level.

To illustrate, consider the following.  Adding bling to a trading pin design dramatically increases its tradeability.  Moving parts like sliders, spinners and danglers create value and fun all at the same time.  Adding glitter to the enamel on a diamond gives the pin a sparkle effect enhancing the pin appeal.

What Are Custom Pin Plating Options

When it comes to creating custom enamel pins, the choice of plating can make a big difference in the final look and feel of your pin. Different plating options offer unique aesthetics and can enhance the overall design. Let's explore some examples of custom pin plating to give you an idea of what is possible.

One popular option is gold plating, which adds a touch of elegance and luxury to any pin design. The warm golden hue creates a striking contrast against colorful enamel fillings, making your design stand out. Another option is silver plating, which exudes sophistication and pairs well with cool tones. It offers a sleek and polished appearance that works beautifully for intricate designs.

For those looking for something more unconventional, antique finishes like bronze or copper are worth considering. These finishes create a vintage or rustic vibe that can add character to your pins. They work particularly well with designs inspired by history or nature.

If fun and cartoonish is the desired look, consider dye metal colors like black, blue, green, red, or yellow.  These colors bring the design to life.

Choosing the right plating for your custom enamel pins can elevate their visual appeal and complement your design concept effectively. Whether you prefer classic gold or silver finishes or want to experiment with unique antique options, there's no shortage of choices when it comes to custom pin plating!

What are My Enamel Pin Attachment Options

When it comes to creating enamel pins, the design is just one piece of the puzzle. Another important aspect to consider is the pin attachment. Pin attachments refer to the mechanisms used to secure your pin onto clothing or accessories.

There are several options for pin attachments, each with its own unique benefits. The most common type of attachment is a butterfly clutch, which features a metal back and a small looped post that slides through the fabric. This simple and secure attachment is perfect for everyday use.

Another popular option is a rubber clutch, which provides added grip and stability compared to butterfly clutches. Rubber clutches are especially useful if you plan on wearing your pins on thicker fabrics or backpacks.

For those looking for an extra touch of style, there are also options like deluxe clutch attachments or even magnetic backings for easy removal without poking holes in delicate fabrics.

Choosing the right pin attachment can enhance both the functionality and aesthetics of your enamel pins. Consider your intended use and personal preferences when deciding which attachment option suits your needs best.

To illustrate, consider the following.  Standard on most pins is the metal butterfly clutch or the rubber clutch.  Both are free and come standard with a pin order.  A deluxe clutch, jewelry clutch, locking pin back or magnet back are all upgrades and add anywhere from $0.35 to $1.00 per pin.

What Are My Enamel Pin Packaging Options

When it comes to pin packaging options, there are a variety of choices available to suit your needs. First, you have the classic option of individual poly bags. This is a simple and cost-effective way to protect your enamel pins during shipping and storage. Each pin is placed in its own clear bag, keeping it safe from scratches or damage.

Another popular choice is custom backing cards. These cards can be designed with your logo or artwork and provide an attractive presentation for your pins. They not only serve as a protective layer but also add professionalism and branding to your product.

If you're looking for something more unique, consider velvet pouches or gift boxes. These options elevate the perceived value of your pins and make them feel like special gifts. Velvet pouches are soft and luxurious, while gift boxes often come in different shapes and sizes.

Choosing the right pin packaging option will depend on your budget, branding goals, and target audience preferences. Whether you opt for simplicity or luxury packaging, ensure that it aligns with the overall aesthetic of your pins for a cohesive brand experience.

To illustrate, consider the following.  Packaging changes a $2.00 item into a $10-$15 item.  Packaging changes the perception of the pin.  Packaging can range from pennies for a backer card up to $5.00 for a special box.  But consider the difference it makes if you are presenting an anniversary pin to an employee, by adding a box you increase the perceived value of the gift and the recognition.  It is worth the cost.

Can Enamel Pins Have Stones

Adding gemstones to your enamel pins can add a touch of elegance and uniqueness. There are several gemstone options available for you to choose from, depending on your preferences and budget. From sparkling rhinestones to vibrant colored gemstones, the choices are endless.

Rhinestones are a popular choice due to their affordability and versatility. They come in various sizes and colors, allowing you to customize your pin design with ease. If you want to make a statement, opt for larger rhinestones that will catch the light and draw attention.

For those looking for more vibrancy, colored gemstones like sapphires or emeralds can be incorporated into your pin design. These precious stones not only add beauty but also symbolize different qualities or meanings.

Whether you prefer subtle sparkle or bold color accents, adding gemstones is an excellent way to elevate your enamel pins' aesthetic appeal. Selecting the right gemstone option will depend on your personal style as well as the overall theme of your pin design. Choose wisely and let these dazzling additions enhance the visual impact of your custom enamel pins.

To illustrate, consider the following.  Rarely are the gemstones in enamel pins real, but the effect is still the same.  Stones typically range from $0.10 cents per stone per pin, so if bling is your thing stones are the best way to show it.

How Does Pin Quantity Affect the Pin Cost?

When it comes to making enamel pins, the quantity you want plays a significant role in determining the overall cost. Generally, the more pins you order, the lower the cost per pin will be. This is because factories can optimize their production process when producing larger quantities.

For instance, if you only need a small number of pins for personal use or as gifts for friends, expect to pay a higher price per pin compared to ordering in bulk. However, keep in mind that there may be minimum order requirements from manufacturers.

If you're planning on selling enamel pins or using them as promotional items, ordering in larger quantities makes financial sense. Not only will you get better pricing but having more inventory allows for greater flexibility and potential profit margins.

Before placing an order with a factory, carefully consider your desired pin quantity and evaluate how it aligns with your budget and goals. Remember that increasing the number of pins ordered can lead to substantial savings without compromising quality or design options!

To illustrate, consider the following.  As an example, here is general pricing you can expect when ordering 100 to 1000 qty of a 1 inch soft enamel pin.  100 qty - $2.60, 500 qty - $1.24, 1000 qty - $1.07.  You can see the more you order the less the per unit cost.

How Does Pin Size Affect the Pin Cost?

Pin size is an important factor to consider when determining the cost of your enamel pins. Generally, larger pins require more materials and production time, which can increase the overall cost. This is because larger pins often have more intricate designs that require additional detailing.

Additionally, larger pins may also necessitate a stronger pin-back to securely hold them in place, adding to the cost. On the other hand, smaller pins are generally more affordable due to their reduced material and labor requirements.

It's worth noting that while size does impact pricing, it shouldn't deter you from creating your desired pin design. Whether big or small, there are options available for every budget. Just keep in mind that larger sizes may come with a higher price tag but can offer greater visual impact and detail.

When deciding on pin size for your custom enamel pins, it's essential to strike a balance between your vision and budget constraints. Consider what works best for your design aesthetics while keeping in mind any potential cost implications associated with different sizes.

To illustrate, consider the following.  As an example, here is general pricing you can expect when ordering 100 to 1000 qty of a 1 vs a 1.5 inch soft enamel pin.  100 qty - $2.60 vs $2.85, 500 qty - $1.24 vs $1.50, 1000 qty - $1.07 vs 1.26.  You can see the larger the size the higher the per unit cost.

How Does Pin Thickness Affect the Pin Cost?

When it comes to making enamel pins, the pin thickness is an important factor that can affect the overall cost. The thickness of pins refers to how thick or thin the metal base of the pins are. Generally, thicker pins tend to be more expensive than thinner ones due to the amount of material required.

Thicker pins are often considered more durable and high-quality because they have a solid and substantial feel. They also allow for more intricate designs and details as there is more depth available for enameling. However, with added thickness comes added cost as it requires extra metal during production.

On the other hand, thinner pins are usually less expensive because they require less material and can be produced at a faster rate. While they may not have the same weight or durability as thicker pins, they still offer plenty of room for creativity in terms of design.

When deciding on pin thickness, it's essential to consider your budget and desired aesthetic. Thicker pins may be worth investing in if you prioritize quality and longevity, but thinner options can still provide beautiful results at a lower cost.

To illustrate, consider the following.  Regular pins are 1.2 to 1.5 mm thick and are priced such.  Some people want a thicker pin to give it substance, weight and perceived value.  2mm is a common thick pin.  You can expect to pay about 10-15% more for a thicker pin.

How Much is the Mold or Setup Cost for a Custom Pin?

When it comes to creating custom enamel pins, one of the costs you may encounter is the mold or setup cost. This cost is associated with the creation of a custom mold that will be used to produce your pins. The exact price of this cost can vary depending on factors such as the complexity of your design and the number of colors involved.

The mold or setup cost typically includes the initial creation of the mold and any necessary adjustments or modifications. It's important to note that once you have paid for the mold, you can use it for future orders without incurring additional setup costs.

While there is no specific price range provided here, it's best to reach out directly to a pin manufacturer for an accurate quote based on your unique design requirements. They will be able to provide you with more detailed information regarding the mold or setup cost involved in bringing your custom pin design to life. So don't hesitate - get in touch with a trusted pin manufacturer today!

To illustrate, consider the following.  More often than not, pin manufacturers offer FREE molds.  Now it’s not really free, because it is factored into the per unit price of the pin but to you it will appear free as there won’t be a separate mold charge.  If you order multiple designs the company may charge a $50 to $75 mold charge for each additional design.

How Does the Base Metal Affect Pin Cost?

When it comes to making enamel pins, the base metal you choose can have a significant impact on the overall cost. The base metal refers to the material that forms the foundation of your pin design. Generally, there are two common options: brass and iron.

Brass is a popular choice for enamel pins due to its durability and ability to hold intricate designs. It is known for its corrosion-resistant properties and can be plated with various finishes such as gold or silver. However, using brass as the base metal usually results in higher manufacturing costs compared to iron.

On the other hand, iron is a more affordable option for those working within a budget. While not as durable as brass, iron can still produce high-quality enamel pins at a lower cost. It's important to note that if you opt for an iron base metal, you may need additional plating or protective measures to ensure longevity.

Choosing between brass and iron depends on your budget and desired outcome for your enamel pins. Consider factors such as design complexity and intended usage when deciding which base metal will work best for your project.

To illustrate, consider the following.  Iron has become the industry standard for base metal.  It is less expensive yet still holds up very well as compared to brass.  Most consumers would never know the difference between a brass pin and an iron pin.  The only way to tell is by holding a magnet to the pin.  If the magnet attracts to the pin it is an iron base as iron is magnetic and brass is not.  The only negative to iron is it can rust if the gold or silver plating wears off and it is exposed to moisture, but this rarely is an issue.  Without complicating the issue, there are also 2 other options for base metal:  copper and zinc alloy.  Copper is priced in between but is a softer metal and zinc alloy is used mainly for a certain type of pin.

How Much Do Enamel Pins with Extra Colors Cost?

Enamel pins with extra colors can add a vibrant and eye-catching element to your pin design. But how much do they cost? The cost of enamel pins with extra colors can vary depending on several factors.

First, the complexity of the design plays a role in determining the cost. Intricate designs that require more colors may incur higher costs due to the additional time and resources needed for production.

The quantity of pins you want to produce will also affect the price. Generally, larger quantities will result in lower unit costs as manufacturers can take advantage of economies of scale.

Keep in mind that customizations such as different metal finishes or pin attachments may also impact the overall cost. It's important to factor in these additional elements when budgeting for your enamel pins with extra colors.

When considering enamel pins with extra colors, it's best to consult with a reliable manufacturer who can provide you with detailed pricing based on your specific requirements.

To illustrate, consider the following.  Most pin companies offer up to 8 colors at no extra cost.  If your design calls for more than 8 colors you can expect to pay $0.05 to $0.10 cents per color per pin.  The bigger negative beyond the cost of extra colors is the increased production time.